Review: The Ministry of Lesbian Affairs, Soho Theatre - fun, flirtation and representation
Review: Britannicus, Lyric Hammersmith - toxic family power struggles and misplaced sympathy

Review: Amy Adams in The Glass Menagerie, Duke of Yorks Theatre - bright sparks but too many questions

Director Jeremy Herrin has chosen to have two actors playing Tom Wingfield in The Glass Menagerie so that when he is acting as narrator, it is an older, maturer Tom.  

The Glass Menagerie Duke of York's Theatre poster

This older Tom, played by Paul Hilton, sets a reflective, melancholy, almost listless tone to the play, but while he hovers around the edges of the stage during certain scenes, where he is absent, it serves to emphasise that this story is his interpretation of events and sometimes conjecture. Tom Glynn-Carney plays the younger Tom.

Amy Adams' Amanda is the antithesis, a matriarch full of bustle and bristle and constantly needling her children.

She is an irritating spark to her despondent and bored son and pushes her shy, nervous daughter Laura (Lizzie Annis) further into her own world. And, she is such a spark that you feel Amanda's absence when she is on stage.

As the play progresses and the prospect of a 'gentleman caller' gets closer, a youthful coquettishness comes out. Adams' Amanda is less a mother concerned about her daughter's future and more someone living out a fantasy rooted in much happier times.

Problem scene

For me, the problem scene was when Laura was alone with her gentlemen caller Jim (Victor Alli). It feels, tonally, as if it's from a different play. Is that the intention? Not having been there, this scene is very much from the imagination of Tom or what the quiet and mentally fragile Laura chooses to relay.

Is what Jim says to Laura what he wishes he said to her, in hindsight? Regardless it felt more assured and relaxed than the scenario would suggest.

The staging was also perplexing. Part abstract - a raised black block with a black, blocky table and no chairs - and part realism.

A huge glass display case containing Laura's glass menagerie dominates the centre of the space. To the right of the raised stage, it looks a bit like a 1940s production studio/work area.

Questions, questions

Is it supposed to reflect how Tom uses trips to the movies to escape his mundane life? Is it purely a visual cue, as that space is rarely used? If so, it feels wasted.

Scenes and images are projected onto a screen behind the performance space. It is where the photo of the absent father appears. Perhaps another device to emphasise Tom's love of the movies?

I couldn't see what the left side of the stage looked like from where I was sitting, as it was the end of the row.

Without any chairs, the actors are left perching on edges, only sitting and seemingly relaxed when not in Amanda's presence. Is that the point?

Having so many questions meant the emotional depth of the play didn't properly land. There were some satisfying and interesting individual elements, but I'm not sure this production of The Glass Menagerie is the sum of its parts.

I'm giving it ⭐️⭐️⭐️.

The Glass Menagerie, Duke of York's Theatre

Written by Tennessee Williams

Directed by Jeremy Herrin

Running time: 2 hours and 25 minutes, including an interval

Booking until 27 August; for more information and tickets head to the website.

Recently reviewed:

The Ministry of Lesbian Affairs, Soho Theatre ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

The Breach, Hampstead Theatre ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Age of Rage, Barbican Theatre ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️